Since a few weeks football is slowly coming back, but sadly most of the matches are now played behind closed doors. If there is one thing that this whole crisis taught us is that football without its fans is absolutely worth nothing. Maybe the saddest thing we’ve seen is the urge of some broadcasters, for example in Germany and Spain who try to recreate fan atmosphere with recorded crowd sound and other forms of artificial support. Fans are hard to replace by these kind of fake things. All this led to discussions inside the European fan scene: leading to a joint statement published by Fans Europe (an independent, democratic, non-profit association of football fans). Read the full statement down below:
The recent return of football behind closed doors has demonstrated that fans are the lifeblood of the game. Their presence in the stands has been sorely missed, and the spectacle we are accustomed to has been absent without them. It is therefore more important now than ever for supporters to be included in discussions that will determine the immediate and long-term future of the game.
These discussions should revolve around three core pillars.
First, the safe return of spectators. The impact of the virus is not evenly distributed—different countries have understandably adopted different measures at different times. Still, the health of players, staff, fans, and the general public must always come first. This means minimising the risk of the virus spreading in all settings. UEFA, national leagues, and football associations have acted in line with this principle, but it must remain our foremost concern. To this end, the return of spectators to stadia must be accompanied by a meaningful consultation with fans’ representatives at every level of the game on health safety protocols and other operational measures.
Second, a recognition that the contribution made by fans is irreplaceable. As such, we have significant concerns regarding attempts by broadcasters to replace or imitate the unique atmosphere produced by fans. Augmented reality technology, pre-recorded chants, and other forms of artificial support represent a rebuke to match-going fans. Empty stadia are a direct consequence of a public health crisis that has impacted every single one of us and the absence of fans cannot be compensated for by a computer simulation aimed at the amusement of television audiences.
Third, multi-stakeholder dialogue on the future of football. The coronavirus crisis has yet again shown that the current model of football is flawed, unfair, and unsustainable. Football needs to change dramatically. And it needs to change for the better. Any reform process must include fan representatives, on a local, national, and European level. Fans must be engaged and involved in decisions that relate to the wider future of the game, including the necessary overhaul of governance structures and financial regulations.
There can be no “return to normal.” Lasting change is needed to make the game sustainable from top to bottom, and fans stand ready to play a part in shaping that change.
Football Supporters Europe (FSE)
Belgian Supporters – Belgium
Danske Fodbold Fans (DFF) – Denmark
Football Supporters’ Association (FSA) – England
Suomen Maajoukkueen Kannattajat (SMJK) – Finland
Association Nationale des Supporters (ANS) – France
Irrésistibles Français (IF) – France
Bundesbehindertenfanarbeitsgemeinschaft (BBAG) – Germany
Bündnis Aktiver Fußballfans (BAFF) – Germany
Netzwerk Frauen im Fußball (F_IN) – Germany
ProFans – Germany
Queer Football Fanclubs (QFF) – Germany
Unsere Kurve (UK) – Germany
Supporterscollectief Nederland – Netherlands
Amalgamation of Official Northern Ireland Supporters’ Clubs (AONISC) – Northern Ireland
Norsk Supporterallianse (NSA) – Norway
Associação Portuguesa de Defesa do Adepto (APDA) – Portugal
Confederation of Republic of Ireland Supporters Clubs (CRISC) – Republic of Ireland
Irish Supporters Network (ISN) – Republic of Ireland
You Boys in Green (YBIG) – Republic of Ireland
Association of Tartan Army Clubs (ATAC) – Scotland
Supporters Direct Scotland – Scotland
Federación de Accionistas y Socios del Fútbol Español (FASFE) – Spain
Svenska Fotbollssupporterunionen (SFSU) – Sweden
Taraftar Hakları Dayanışma Derneği (Taraf-Der) – Turkey
Taraftar Hakları Derneği (THD) – Turkey
FSA Cymru – Wales